Cisco Umbrella Alternatives (2026)

Cisco
Cisco Umbrella
4.4 (274) · G2 8.0/10
From Custom quote
Visit website →
Starting price
Custom quote
Free trial
14 days
Deployment
Cloud
Best for
Enterprises wanting DNS-layer security that scales up into a full secure internet gateway (SIG)

Our verdict

The top alternatives to Cisco Umbrella are DNSFilter, Cloudflare Gateway, Webroot DNS Protection. DNSFilter is the closest like-for-like option (4.6/5 (~239 G2 reviews), from $1/user/mo). People typically switch from Cisco Umbrella over pricing model, complexity, or a missing capability — the table compares each alternative on exactly those axes.

  1. 1DNSFilter

    ★ Editor's Choice 8.1 4.6 (239)

    Best for MSPs and SMBs wanting fast, transparently-priced DNS filtering with strong multi-tenancy.

    • AI-driven DNS threat blocking
    • Category + content filtering
    • Roaming clients (Win/Mac/mobile)
    • Multi-tenant MSP console
    Free trial Free version
    Visit DNSFilter → From $1/user/mo Cisco Umbrella vs DNSFilter →

  2. 2Cloudflare Gateway

    7.7

    Best for Teams wanting free DNS + web filtering on Cloudflare's edge, scaling into full SWG.

    • DNS + HTTP filtering
    • Edge-delivered on 330+ cities
    • Category + security filtering
    • Secure web gateway (SWG)
    Free trial Free version
    Visit Cloudflare Gateway → From $7/user/mo Cisco Umbrella vs Cloudflare Gateway →

  3. 3Webroot DNS Protection

    7.7 4.4 (86)

    Best for MSPs already running Webroot endpoint security wanting an integrated DNS-layer add-on.

    • DNS-layer filtering + threat blocking
    • Blocks DNS-over-HTTPS threats
    • Policy enforcement by group
    • Integrates with Webroot endpoint
    Free trial Free version
    Visit Webroot DNS Protection → From Custom quote Cisco Umbrella vs Webroot DNS Protection →

  4. 4Control D

    7.5

    Best for SMBs and MSPs wanting flat, no-minimum DNS filtering with deep customization.

    • Customizable DNS filtering
    • Per-device + per-profile policies
    • Malware + ad + tracker blocking
    • No minimums or contracts
    Free trial Free version
    Visit Control D → From $2/endpoint/mo Cisco Umbrella vs Control D →

Affiliate links — vendors may pay us a commission. Ranking is data-driven and never pay-to-play. How we rank →

Frequently asked questions

What is the best alternative to Cisco Umbrella?
DNSFilter is the top-rated alternative in our data-weighted ranking (from $1/user/mo).
Why do people switch from Cisco Umbrella?
Usually pricing model, complexity, or a missing capability. The table compares each alternative on exactly those axes.
Data as of June 1, 2026. Sources: umbrella.cisco.com, g2.com. Figures are pulled from public vendor and security data and refreshed automatically.